TasteHi HomepageTasteHi Logo
Big Island•Hawaii

Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island

Looking for top-rated italian restaurants in Big Island? These are our recommended spots for 2026, based on local reviews, menus, and photos.

Italian in Hawaii

View all islands

Italian in Hawaii

View island-wide spots

Noodle shops in Big Island

Popular option

Sandwich shops in Big Island

Popular option

American in Big Island

Popular option

All 25 Top-Rated Italian Restaurants in Big Island

5
Christine's Deli - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
4.6(36 reviews)

Christine's Deli

Kailua-Kona • 75-159 Lunapule Rd Ste 1 Walua Plaza, Kailua-Kona, Hawaii, 96740-2100

6
Cafe il Mondo - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
4.5(291 reviews)

Cafe il Mondo

Honokaa • 45-3580 Mamane St, Honokaa, Hawaii, 96727-6973

7
Pizza Rovers - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
4.5(11 reviews)

Pizza Rovers

Kailua-Kona • 78 Ehukai St., Kailua-Kona, Hawaii, 96740

Paolo's Bistro - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
4.4(181 reviews)

Paolo's Bistro

Pahoa • 15-2951 Old Government Road, Pahoa, Hawaii, 96778

Pueo's Osteria - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
4.4(1,368 reviews)

Pueo's Osteria

Waikoloa • 68-1820 Waikoloa Rd, Waikoloa, Hawaii, 96738

Cafe Pesto Hilo Bay - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
4.3(1,973 reviews)

Cafe Pesto Hilo Bay

Hilo • 308 Kamehameha Ave Suite 101, Hilo, Hawaii, 96720-2960

Popover - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
4.2(20 reviews)

Popover

Hilo • 399 E Kawili St, Hilo, Hawaii, 96720-5056

Pizza Hawaii - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
4.1(44 reviews)

Pizza Hawaii

Hilo • 2100 Kanoelehua Ave, Hilo, Hawaii, 96720-6500

Pizza Ala Slice - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
4.0(4 reviews)

Pizza Ala Slice

Hilo • 111 E Puainako St 111. E. Puainako St., Hilo, Hawaii, 96720-5288

Bianellis Kona - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
4.0(675 reviews)

Bianellis Kona

Kailua-Kona • 78-6831 Alii Dr Keauhou Shopping Center, Kailua-Kona, Hawaii, 96740

Walua Social Club - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
3.9(13 reviews)

Walua Social Club

Kailua-Kona • 75-5864 Walua Rd, Kailua-Kona, Hawaii, 96740-1318

Nui Italian - Best Italian Restaurants in Big Island
3.5(230 reviews)

Nui Italian

Waikoloa • 69-425 Waikoloa Beach Drive Hilton Waikoloa Village, Waikoloa, Hawaii, 96738

Dining Highlights: Finding Great Italian in Big Island

Local Ingredients & Flavor

Enjoy authentic italian prepared with fresh island-sourced ingredients, daily catches, and local Hawaiian seasoning.

Atmosphere & Seating

From casual beachside shacks and food trucks to oceanfront fine dining, find the ideal setting for romantic dinners or family meals in Big Island.

Menus, Prices & Hours

Check price range indicators ($ to $$$$), operating hours, reservations, and customer ratings before visiting Big Island dining spots.

Frequently Asked Questions about Italian in Big Island

Everything you need to know about dining at italian restaurants in Big Island, Hawaii.

Top-rated italian spots in Big Island include Aloha De Nada Empanadas, Gypsea Gelato (79-7491 Mamalahoa Hwy), Nicoco Hawaiian Gelato. These are selected based on customer ratings, service quality, and popular menu items.
Explore the best Italian Restaurants in Big Island, Hawaii, Hawaii. Discover top-rated dining venues serving italian in Big Island. Read guest reviews, check ratings, view menus, and get directions easily. Plan your dining experience or explore other cuisines, islands, or dining features with our local filters. Learn more on TasteHi.

More Food & Dining Guides in Big Island

Plan Your Hawaii Trip

▼
1-Day Hawaii Food Itinerary3-Day Hawaii Food Itinerary5-Day Hawaii Food Itinerary7-Day Hawaii Food ItineraryAll Hawaii Food Itineraries

Other Cuisines in Big Island

▼
Noodle shops in Big IslandSandwich shops in Big IslandAmerican in Big IslandBreakfast in Big IslandFood delivery services in Big IslandCafe in Big IslandBakeries in Big IslandQuick Bites in Big IslandHawaiian in Big IslandDessert in Big IslandFast Food in Big IslandMexican in Big IslandVegan in Big IslandVegan options in Big IslandContemporary in Big Island

Popular Dining Features in Big Island

▼
Accepts Credit Cards in Big IslandAsian-owned in Big IslandBar in Big IslandBreakfast in Big IslandBrunch in Big IslandBuffet in Big IslandCheap Eats in Big IslandContemporary in Big IslandDelivery in Big IslandDigital Payments in Big IslandDinner in Big IslandDrinks in Big IslandFamily Style in Big IslandFull Bar in Big IslandGluten Free Options in Big Island