TasteHi HomepageTasteHi Logo
Maui•Hawaii

Best Italian Restaurants in Maui

Looking for top-rated italian restaurants in Maui? These are our recommended spots for 2026, based on local reviews, menus, and photos.

Italian in Hawaii

View all islands

Italian in Hawaii

View island-wide spots

American in Maui

Popular option

Hawaiian in Maui

Popular option

Noodle shops in Maui

Popular option

All 28 Top-Rated Italian Restaurants in Maui

1
Cafe At The Point - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
5.0(2 reviews)

Cafe At The Point

Kula • 4051 Omaopio Rd # 1 At Hawaii Sea Spirits, Kula, Hawaii, 96790-8828

3
Belly Maui - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.6(61 reviews)

Belly Maui

Lahaina • 2580 Kekaa Dr Unit I1/I2, Lahaina, Hawaii, 96761

6
808 Old Town - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.5(243 reviews)

808 Old Town

Wailuku • 2051 Main St, Wailuku, Hawaii, 96793-1648

8
Matteo's Osteria - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.4(1,255 reviews)

Matteo's Osteria

Wailea • 161 Wailea Ike Pl Suite A107, Wailea, Hawaii, 96753-6521

Pizza Madness Maui - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.3(553 reviews)

Pizza Madness Maui

Kihei • 1455 S Kihei Rd Ste 2, Kihei, Hawaii, 96753-8189

Pita - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.3(1,081 reviews)

Pita

Wailea • 34 Wailea Gateway Pl Unit A-108, Wailea, Hawaii, 96753

Fabiani's - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.3(971 reviews)

Fabiani's

Kihei • 95 Lipoa Street Suite 101, Kihei, Hawaii, 96753

Nikki's Pizza - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.2(3 reviews)

Nikki's Pizza

Maui • 2435 Kaanapali Pkwy Ste H19, Lahaina, Maui, HI 96761-1980

Olivine - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.1(50 reviews)

Olivine

Wailea • 3850 Wailea Alanui Dr Grand Wailea, A Waldorf Astoria Resort, Wailea, Hawaii, 96753

Pizza Fresh - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.1(37 reviews)

Pizza Fresh

Makawao • 1043 Makawao Ave, Makawao, Hawaii, 96768-9465

Via! By Sale Pepe - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.0(61 reviews)

Via! By Sale Pepe

Lahaina • 2435 Ka'anapali Parkway Suite H-19, Lahaina, Hawaii, 96761

Bistro Casanova - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.0(400 reviews)

Bistro Casanova

Kahului • 33 Lono Ave Ste 150, Kahului, Hawaii, 96732-1633

Pizza Paradiso - Best Italian Restaurants in Maui
4.0(975 reviews)

Pizza Paradiso

Lahaina • 3350 Lower Honoapiilani Rd Ste 208, Lahaina, Hawaii, 96761

Dining Highlights: Finding Great Italian in Maui

Local Ingredients & Flavor

Enjoy authentic italian prepared with fresh island-sourced ingredients, daily catches, and local Hawaiian seasoning.

Atmosphere & Seating

From casual beachside shacks and food trucks to oceanfront fine dining, find the ideal setting for romantic dinners or family meals in Maui.

Menus, Prices & Hours

Check price range indicators ($ to $$$$), operating hours, reservations, and customer ratings before visiting Maui dining spots.

Frequently Asked Questions about Italian in Maui

Everything you need to know about dining at italian restaurants in Maui, Hawaii.

Top-rated italian spots in Maui include Cafe At The Point, Momona Bakery And Coffee Shop, Belly Maui. These are selected based on customer ratings, service quality, and popular menu items.
Explore the best Italian Restaurants in Maui, Hawaii, Hawaii. Discover top-rated dining venues serving italian in Maui. Read guest reviews, check ratings, view menus, and get directions easily. Plan your dining experience or explore other cuisines, islands, or dining features with our local filters. Learn more on TasteHi.

More Food & Dining Guides in Maui

Plan Your Hawaii Trip

▼
1-Day Hawaii Food Itinerary3-Day Hawaii Food Itinerary5-Day Hawaii Food Itinerary7-Day Hawaii Food ItineraryAll Hawaii Food Itineraries

Other Cuisines in Maui

▼
American in MauiHawaiian in MauiNoodle shops in MauiQuick Bites in MauiBreakfast in MauiFast Food in MauiBakeries in MauiVegetarian friendly in MauiSeafood in MauiDessert in MauiPizza in MauiSandwich shops in MauiCafe in MauiFood delivery services in MauiDeli in Maui

Popular Dining Features in Maui

▼
Accepts Credit Cards in MauiAsian-owned in MauiBar in MauiBlack-owned in MauiBreakfast in MauiBrunch in MauiBuffet in MauiCheap Eats in MauiContemporary in MauiDelivery in MauiDigital Payments in MauiDinner in MauiDrinks in MauiFamily Style in MauiFull Bar in Maui