TasteHi HomepageTasteHi Logo
Pizza Madness Maui - Hawaii Restaurant
#4 of 108 Restaurants in Kihei Italian

Pizza Madness Maui

4.3(553 community reviews)
Budget ($)
PizzaItalianVegan restaurantsNoodle shopsVegan options

About

Discover Pizza Madness Maui, offering the best Pizza experience in Kihei. Enjoy Budget ($) meals, explore their menu, and read reviews from the community on TasteHi.

A Slice of Local Life in Kihei

When you walk into Pizza Madness, the first thing that hits you is the unmistakable aroma of toasted dough and bubbling mozzarella. This isn't your typical tourist-trap pizzeria. Tucked away in the heart of the South Maui coast, it serves as a community staple where the locals go when they want a pie that actually has some backbone. The interior is unpretentious, sporting a laid-back, surf-town aesthetic that makes it the perfect stop after a morning of snorkeling at Kamaole Beach.

Crafting the Maui Crust

What sets the kitchen apart here is the commitment to the classics. They lean into a traditional hand-tossed style that achieves a satisfying crunch without sacrificing the chewiness of the crust. If you're a fan of bold flavors, the signature pies often incorporate local ingredients, with the Garlic Chicken pizza standing out as a consistent crowd-pleaser. The sauce strikes a balance between bright acidity and savory herb notes, pairing perfectly with the cooler island breeze that drifts in from the open doors.

The South Maui Experience

Be prepared for a bustling, high-energy environment. During peak hours, the chatter of families and the clinking of local brew bottles create a lively soundtrack. It’s tight quarters, and you might find yourself shoulder-to-shoulder with surfers or residents grabbing a quick bite before heading back out to the water. While parking in the Kihei commercial centers can sometimes be a test of patience, the reward of a fresh, piping-hot thin crust is worth the minor hassle. Whether you're fueling up for a drive to Hana or just looking for a reliable dinner spot without the pretension, this is where you go to eat like you live on the island.

Amenities & Features

Dinner in Kihei
Lunch in Kihei
Accepts Credit Cards in Kihei
Vegetarian friendly in Kihei
Vegan options in Kihei

Location

1455 S Kihei Rd Ste 2, Kihei, Hawaii, 96753-8189

Directions

More to Explore

More cuisines in Kihei

▼
African in KiheiAmerican in KiheiArgentinean in KiheiAsian in KiheiBakeries in KiheiBar in KiheiBarbecue in KiheiBeer in KiheiBreakfast in KiheiBrew Pub in KiheiBurgers in KiheiCafe in KiheiCaribbean in KiheiCasual dining in KiheiChicken in Kihei

Plan Your Maui Trip

▼
1-Day Maui Food Itinerary3-Day Maui Food Itinerary5-Day Maui Food Itinerary7-Day Maui Food ItineraryAll Hawaii Food Itineraries

Reviews

Showing 6 of 553 community reviews
A

Anthony D.Google Maps

Recently

Didn’t eat in so service and atmosphere don’t really apply. A disgusting undercooked pool of cheese with very small amount of toppings. Can’t even tell the where the pieces of pizza were cut, all melted together! Definitely never ordered the pizza rare. Spend $33 on a pepperoni pizza somewhere else!

M

Melissa PerezGoogle Maps

Recently

BEST PIZZA! AMAZING SERICE!! SO MUCH FUN FOR ALL AGES!! (Free arcade and toys to play with!!) KRISTAN and all the gals were the most friendly and impressive staff from start to finish. We always feel so welcomed and comfortable with the family and food is always yummy and fresh tasting! Raises the bar for dining on Maui!

C

Chris & Andie MullerGoogle Maps

Recently

Pizza was good, not great. Alfredo had little to no sauce on it. Philly cheesesteak had no cheese?? Service was great. Nothing was "bad" but definitely not what we are used to. Wouldn't come back.

V

Vyshnavi ReddyGoogle Maps

Recently

We have ordered jalapeño poppers and veggie pizza. We couldn’t even complete 2 slices of pizza, it was tasting very bad. Do not order pizza here, you will be disappointed for sure. The pizza crust also tasted very bad.jalapeños poppers tasted like they have reheated the frozen ones

J

Josie LGoogle Maps

Recently

Great food & very friendly staff. One of our best dining experiences on Maui! Happy hour wings are A+++. Also shared a 1/2 meat lovers and half bbq chicken pizza and as a Chicago transplant, I can honestly say this is the best pizza we've had anywhere in a very long time. Good beer selection served ice cold. Delicious ice cream cookie sandwiches. Ordered the cinnamon bites to go and they are addictive!! Lastly, the service from Keno was phenomenal! His Aloha welcoming spirit made for a memorable dining experience. We highly recommend this gem of a restaurant.

R

Ronda KittsGoogle Maps

Recently

Easy five stars! I regularly go here for dinner, or a beer and a bite while running Kihei errands. As far as food goes, their pizza is FANTASTIC; reminds me of my childhood pizza place l'd go to growing up. I've also had their philly cheese steaks and wings which are awesome. Plus they make their own ranch! | put it on everything. Staff is always friendly and personable, and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming! Highly recommend

Comments & Reviews

Please sign in to write a review.

No reviews yet. Be the first to write a review!

Frequently Asked Questions about Pizza Madness Maui

Common questions from diners about Pizza Madness Maui in Kihei.

Yes, the restaurant is vegetarian-friendly and offers vegan options.

Nearby Restaurants

Johana
$$
0.0(0)

Johana

Restaurant

Kihei
Suns Out Buns Out
$$
0.0(0)

Suns Out Buns Out

Street Food

Kihei
Johana chicken - Maui Restaurant Image
$$
5.0(1)

Johana chicken

Hawaiian

Kihei

Explore Kihei