Maui Pie - Kihei Restaurant Image

Maui Pie

4.6(504 community reviews)
Moderate ($$)

About

Discover Maui Pie, offering the best American experience in Kihei. Enjoy Moderate ($$) meals, explore their menu, and read reviews from the community on TasteHi.

A Slice of Paradise in Kihei

If you find yourself cruising through South Maui, the sweet, buttery aroma wafting toward the sidewalk usually means you have arrived at Maui Pie. This local staple is less about white-tablecloth pretense and more about the honest, flaky satisfaction of a pie made from scratch. The atmosphere is casual and unhurried, the kind of place where locals grab a quick slice after a morning surf session or pick up a whole pie for a beachside sunset picnic.

The Art of the Crust

The menu leans heavily into island-inspired flavors alongside traditional favorites. The lilikoi chiffon pie is a standout, capturing the bright, tart essence of passion fruit, while the classic apple and cherry varieties offer a comforting, nostalgic bite. Each crust is hand-rolled with just the right amount of lard and butter, creating that distinctive, shatter-crisp texture that only comes from traditional baking methods. Because everything is baked on-site throughout the day, the fillings are always fresh, never syrupy.

Things to Know Before You Go

Space inside is limited, so expect a cozy, tight-knit environment. While the counter staff is efficient, the popularity of their savory pot pies—particularly the chicken and vegetable variations—means they occasionally sell out before the dinner rush hits. Parking in the plaza can be a bit of a shuffle during peak lunch hours, but the tradeoff is getting your hands on a warm pastry that feels like a genuine piece of Maui culinary history. It is the perfect spot for families needing a quick treat or anyone looking to skip the generic hotel dessert options in favor of something made with local soul.

Photos

Maui Pie - Kihei Restaurant Image
Maui Pie - Kihei Restaurant Image
Maui Pie - Kihei Restaurant Image
Maui Pie - Kihei Restaurant Image
Maui Pie - Kihei Restaurant Image

Location

1280 S Kihei Rd Azeka Marketplace, Kihei, Hawaii, 96753-8240

Directions

Reviews

Showing 7 of 504 community reviews
P

Paula ChavezGoogle Maps

Recently

The Lilikoi pie was great! So was the mango strawberry pie! Would come back, great quality. I also love the atmosphere, the music was so good, honestly obsessed.

D

Daniel ChavezGoogle Maps

Recently

Amazing service and dessert options. All their pies were really good, our favourite was by far the lilikoi (passion fruit). We tried the coconut cream and strawberry-mango and they were both really good.

N

Natalia ChavezGoogle Maps

Recently

Had this for dessert and was really good! We had the coconut cream,passion fruit, and mango strawberry pies. My personal favorite was the passion fruit one but they were all amazing! The service and atmosphere just made it better! Would definitely recommend.

J

J. MorontaGoogle Maps

Recently

What a great pie shop. We tried the Mango Strawberry, Coconut Cream, and Lilikoi pies, and they were all delicious. The flavors were perfectly balanced, and each one had its own unique character. Our favorite was the Lilikoi pie. It was absolutely fantastic. The cozy atmosphere and genuinely kind people made the experience even better.

E

Erica JacksonGoogle Maps

Recently

Maui Pie is a charming little shop where all the pies are made fresh onsite, and you can absolutely taste the difference. They offer several flavors available by the slice, mini pie, or full sized pie, so there’s an option for every appetite. I had a slice of the coconut cream pie and it was excellent, a perfectly flaky crust with a rich, flavorful filling. Cute shop, great service, and good pie. A must stop for anyone with a sweet tooth in Maui.

A

AGoogle Maps

Recently

The crumb is really delicious and spiced almost like chai. We got the mountain Berry fruit pie and loved it. All the fruit pies happen to be vegan as well which is great!

J

JamesGoogle Maps

Recently

Maui Pie in Kihei is hands down the best pie on the island. The pies are made fresh on site and they have several different flavors. Pies are available by the slice or mini pie or regular size pie. I have had the Peanut Butter Chocolate and the Blueberry Pie with ice cream. My wife had Raspberry Peach with Ice cream. All were excellent! Shop has good vibes and the service is awesome!

Comments & Reviews

Please sign in to write a review.

No reviews yet. Be the first to write a review!

Frequently Asked Questions about Maui Pie

Common questions from diners about Maui Pie in Kihei.

Yes, Maui Pie is listed as vegetarian friendly.

Nearby Restaurants

Johana
$$
0.0(0)

Johana

Restaurant

Kihei
Suns Out Buns Out
$$
0.0(0)

Suns Out Buns Out

Street Food

Kihei
Johana chicken - Maui Restaurant Image
$$
5.0(1)

Johana chicken

Hawaiian

Kihei