TasteHi HomepageTasteHi Logo
Paia•Maui

Best Seafood Restaurants in Paia

Looking for top-rated seafood restaurants in Paia? These are our recommended spots for 2026, based on local reviews, menus, and photos.

Seafood in Hawaii

View all islands

Seafood in Maui

View island-wide spots

Noodle shops in Paia

Popular option

Breakfast in Paia

Popular option

Gluten free options in Paia

Popular option

Top 3 Seafood Restaurants in Paia

Dining Highlights: Finding Great Seafood in Paia

Local Ingredients & Flavor

Enjoy authentic seafood prepared with fresh island-sourced ingredients, daily catches, and local Hawaiian seasoning.

Atmosphere & Seating

From casual beachside shacks and food trucks to oceanfront fine dining, find the ideal setting for romantic dinners or family meals in Paia.

Menus, Prices & Hours

Check price range indicators ($ to $$$$), operating hours, reservations, and customer ratings before visiting Paia dining spots.

Frequently Asked Questions about Seafood in Paia

Everything you need to know about dining at seafood restaurants in Paia, Maui.

Top-rated seafood spots in Paia include Mama's Fish House, Island Fresh Cafe, Paia Fish Market (100 Hana Hwy). These are selected based on customer ratings, service quality, and popular menu items.
Explore the best Seafood Restaurants in Paia, Maui, Hawaii. Discover top-rated dining venues serving seafood in Paia. Read guest reviews, check ratings, view menus, and get directions easily. Plan your dining experience or explore other cuisines, islands, or dining features with our local filters. Learn more on TasteHi.

More Food & Dining Guides in Paia

Plan Your Maui Trip

▼
1-Day Maui Food Itinerary3-Day Maui Food Itinerary5-Day Maui Food Itinerary7-Day Maui Food ItineraryAll Hawaii Food Itineraries

Other Cuisines in Paia

▼
Noodle shops in PaiaBreakfast in PaiaGluten free options in PaiaVegan in PaiaVegan options in PaiaCafe in PaiaAmerican in PaiaHawaiian in PaiaHealthy in PaiaBar in PaiaHawaiian Shave Ice & Ice Cream in PaiaAsian in PaiaSouth American in PaiaThai in PaiaDesserts in Paia

Seafood Restaurants in Neighboring Cities

▼
Seafood Restaurants in KiheiSeafood Restaurants in WaileaSeafood Restaurants in KahuluiSeafood Restaurants in WailukuSeafood Restaurants in KapaluaSeafood Restaurants in MakawaoSeafood Restaurants in Hana

Popular Dining Features in Paia

▼
Accepts Credit Cards in PaiaAsian-owned in PaiaBar in PaiaBreakfast in PaiaBrunch in PaiaContemporary in PaiaDigital Payments in PaiaDinner in PaiaDrinks in PaiaFamily Style in PaiaFull Bar in PaiaGluten Free Options in PaiaHighchairs Available in PaiaHispanic/Latinx-owned in PaiaLate Night in Paia